Skip to main content
Page header background image

Legal Updates

Unclaimed, Not Abandoned: Why House Bill 480 Misses The Mark

The Ohio General Assembly enacted a statutory scheme designed to preserve and return private property.  The Ohio Unclaimed Funds Act, Revised Code Chapter 169, provides a way for individuals and businesses to recover property held in trust by the Ohio Department of Commerce, (the “Department”) through its Division of Unclaimed Funds (the “Division”).  Consistent with that purpose, the Division states that it “works to locate the rightful owners and return their hard-earned, but forgotten, money.”[i] In its most recent annual report, the Department likewise reports that a new platform for reporting and claiming unclaimed funds produced an “historic increase in claims submitted, allowing the Division to return more money to Ohioans in FY 2026 than ever before.”[ii]

Despite those policies and efforts to reunite Ohioans with their private property, the General Assembly is considering House Bill 480[iii], which contains amendments that, if adopted, would reduce the amount of unclaimed property returned to its rightful owners.  Just as troubling, the proposed legislation would violate at least two articles of the Ohio Constitution.

How Ohio’s Unclaimed Funds Act Works

A “Holder” is a person that has possession, custody or control of property owed to another.  An "Owner" is any person entitled to receive, or have an interest in or claim against, that property.  When property is inactive for certain prescribed periods of time, the holder reports it to the Division and, depending on the amount reported, pays some or all of it into the state’s unclaimed funds trust fund.

An owner that wishes to recover its property may file a claim with the Division, and the Division must pay the amount of the property, plus interest, to a claimant that establishes its right to payment.  There is no minimum value for a holder to report property, and no minimum value for property to qualify as unclaimed.  An owner can recover any property reported to the Division, whatever its value.

House Bill 480 Violates The Ohio Constitution

House Bill 480 was introduced in September 2025 and referred for hearing before the Technology and Innovation Committee on November 9, 2026.  It contains two amendments that would result in the state taking private property.  Those changes and their flaws are explained below.

1. Adding a value threshold to the definition of “unclaimed funds” would convert private property into state property.

    Ohio Revised Code Section 169.01(B)(1) currently defines “unclaimed funds” as “any moneys, rights to moneys, or intangible property” that remains dormant for the statutory period.  Value has no bearing on whether property is unclaimed funds or whether it can be recovered.  House Bill 480 Section 169.01(B)(1) would change that by limiting “unclaimed funds” to property worth $25 or more in total per owner.

    Ohio Revised Code Section 169.08 gives owners the right to recover their property from the state as follows: “Any person claiming a property interest in unclaimed funds delivered or reported to the state . . .  may file a claim thereto on the form prescribed by the director of commerce.” Under the bill’s new definition of unclaimed funds, that right would depend on the owner’s property being worth $25 or more.  By imposing a value threshold for private property to be recoverable, the General Assembly would allow the Department to reject any claim for property worth less than $25 on the ground that such property is no longer considered “unclaimed funds.” In other words, the state could keep that property forever. 

    The sums are significant.  Although 2026 data is unavailable, in 2020 the state held $59 million in unclaimed properties valued under $25, and holders reported $3.2 million in such properties that year[iv].  Because the unclaimed funds trust has grown significantly from $3.2 billion in 2020 to $5.4 billion currently[v], the value of properties under $25 has very likely grown as well. 

    Refusing to return unclaimed property worth less than $25 violates Article I, Section 19 of the Ohio Constitution, which provides that private property “shall ever be held inviolate” and may not be taken without compensation as assessed by a jury.  The Ohio Supreme Court has relied on this provision to strike down a similar attempt by the General Assembly to allow the state to retain private property.  Sogg v. Zurz, 121 Ohio St.3d 449 (2009).  Sogg challenged the constitutionality of the first sentence of former Revised Code 169.08(D), which allowed the state to retain the interest earned on unclaimed funds.  The court held that provision unconstitutional, stating in relevant part: “This declaration is breathtakingly bold and strikes at the core of the concept of private property because, at a stroke, the General Assembly severed the link between the owner of an asset and the income produced by that asset.” Ohio Const. at. I, § 19.  The court further observed that “[u]nclaimed funds never become the property of the holder or the state of Ohio,” that “[u]nclaimed monies are held in trust in perpetuity for the benefit of owners of the unclaimed property,” and that “‘[u]nclaimed funds’ are not abandoned; they are the property of their owner.”

    Ohio’s Tenth District Court of Appeals relied on Sogg in Avaya Inc. v. Ohio Department of Commerce, 2021-Ohio-4626, in which the court recognized: “That money is not the government’s: The Division’s job is to hold it in trust only until it can be turned over to its rightful owner.” 

    Under the Ohio Constitution, Sogg,and Avaya, private property does not become state property because its value is less than $25.  Even if such a legal maxim existed, the state would still have to compensate the owner under Article I, Section 19.  Writing a value threshold into the definition of “unclaimed funds” is unconstitutional and would deny Ohioans the right to recover many millions of dollars of their own property.

    Section 169.03(K) of House Bill 480 confirms this consequence, which is hopefully unintended.  It states: “Notwithstanding any provision in the law to the contrary, nothing shall prevent a holder from voluntarily making any property subject to the reporting requirements of this section, if that property has a value of less than twenty-five dollars.” Accordingly, House Bill 480 would therefore permit holders to report and pay property worth under $25 into the trust fund, even though that property would no longer meet the definition of “unclaimed funds” and so could not be recovered.  That result is the opposite of reunification.

    2.  Is the General Assembly attempting to regulate the practice of law?

    A second provision of House Bill 480 that could reduce the property returned to its rightful owners appears to prohibit attorneys from advising clients about their unclaimed property rights unless the Department first registers the attorney.  Current Revised Code 169.16(A) provides that “[n]o person, on behalf of any other person, shall engage in any activity for the purpose of locating, delivering, recovering, or assisting in the recovery of unclaimed funds . . . and receive a fee, compensation, commission, or other remuneration for such activity without first having obtained a certificate of registration from the director of commerce.”  That registration requirement applies to professional claimant representatives, commonly known as “finders,” whom owners hire to locate and claim their property.

    House Bill 480 could extend this registration mandate to attorneys through proposed new Section 169.16(F), which reads: “The person seeking a certificate of registration may be an attorney whose performance of services to locate, deliver, recover or assist in the recovery of unclaimed funds . . . is one of the primary purposes of the attorney’s representation of the attorney’s client.” If an attorney then provides legal services[vi] to help an owner recover his, her, or its private property without the Department’s prior approval, that attorney could be found guilty of a criminal offense.  See R.C. 169.99(B).

    This new language raises serious problems.  Article IV, Section 2(B)(1)(g) of the Ohio Constitution gives the Ohio Supreme Court original jurisdiction over “[a]dmission to the practice of law, the discipline of persons so admitted, and all other matters relating to the practice of law.”  For nearly 90 years, the Ohio Supreme Court has held that it has exclusive authority to regulate, control, and define the practice of law.  Judd v. City Trust & Savings Bank, 133 Ohio St. 81 (1937).  Because of that exclusive power, the court is the “ultimate authority” on who may practice law, including before administrative agencies.  Cleveland Bar Assn. v. CompManagement, Inc., 104 Ohio St.3d 168 (2004).  Rules of general application that limit an attorney’s ability to practice law or impose across-the-board disciplinary measures on members of the bar fall within the court’s exclusive jurisdiction.  Melling v.  Stralka, 12 Ohio St.3d 105 (1984).  Any attempt by the General Assembly to regulate attorney conduct intrudes on that jurisdiction of the Ohio Supreme Court and violates the separation of powers. 

    Nor can the General Assembly plausibly argue that providing legal services to recover unclaimed property is not the practice of law.  Revised Code 169.08(G) provides that when a claimant succeeds on administrative appeal from the Department’s denial of a claim, “the claimant shall be reimbursed for reasonable attorney's fees.” If the General Assembly truly intends to require attorneys to register with the Department before they may practice law, proposed Section 169.16(F) is unconstitutional on its face.  If the state instead applies Revised Code Section 169.16(F) or Section 169.16(A) to attorneys, which has never been done, that statute would be unconstitutional as applied.

    Conclusion

    House Bill 480 is not all bad.  It contains several amendments designed to help return private property held in trust by the state.  However, the provisions explained above would seriously undermine that purpose, leave fewer Ohioans reunited with their private property, and deprive Ohioans of their constitutional rights.


    [i] Ohio Department of Commerce, What Are Unclaimed Funds, https://com.ohio.gov/divisions-and-programs/unclaimed-funds/about-unclaimed-funds.

    [ii] Ohio Department of Commerce, Annua Report FY 2026, https://dam.assets.ohio.gov/image/upload/com.ohio.gov/ADMIN/Annual%20Report/Ohio_Dept_of_Commerce_Annual_Report_FY_2026.pdf.

    [iii] H.B.  480, 136th Gen.  Assemb.  (Ohio 2025) https://www.legislature.ohio.gov/legislation/136/hb480.

    [iv] https://www.legislature.ohio.gov/legislation/134/hb348/committee

    [v] See notes 4 and 2.

    [vi] Legal services provided to owners include: (1) interpreting the law; (2) advising the owner of its legal rights, including property rights; (3) advising on evidentiary requirements for recovery, e.g., the burden of proof; (4) advising the owner on what evidence to present, how to present it, its admissibility and its sufficiency, e.g., whether it proves the right to recover by a preponderance of the evidence; (5) presenting evidence and argument to state agencies in writing and/or at hearing; (6) advising on case strategy, including appeal options; and (7) presenting evidence and argument to state courts.

    Services