Careers

Diversity, Equity & Inclusion

Experience

Innovation

Interactive Maps

Locations

About

Pages

Meet our team of innovators
Ask us how we do it

Professionals

Insights

Services

Thompson Hine LLP, a full-service business law firm with approximately 400 lawyers in 8 offices, was ranked number 1 in the category “Most innovative North American law firms: New working models” by The Financial Times and was 1 of 7 firms shortlisted for The American Lawyer’s inaugural Legal Services Innovation Award. The firm has been recognized by the National Law Journal as a Legal Technology Trailblazer and featured by Bloomberg for its innovative service delivery models, which drive accuracy and predictability. The firm’s commitment to innovation is embodied in Thompson Hine SmartPaTHTM – a smarter way to work – predictable, efficient and aligned with client goals. For more information, please visit ThompsonHine.com and ThompsonHine.com/SmartPaTH.

Home | Thompson Hine LLP

Atlanta

Chicago

Cincinnati

Cleveland

Columbus

Dayton

New York

Washington, D.C.

core/separator

core/heading

core/list

The U.S. Department of Commerce’s Bureau of Industry and Security (BIS) published in the Federal Register on August 27, 2020 an <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2020/08/27/2020-18910/identification-and-review-of-controls-for-certain-foundational-technologies">advance notice of proposed rulemaking</a> (ANPRM) for foundational technologies.&nbsp; BIS is soliciting public comments until October 26, 2020 to help identify foundational technologies essential to U.S. national security (“Foundational Technologies ANPRM”).&nbsp; This long-awaited ANPRM marks the start of an intra-agency review process implementing a key provision of the Export Control Reform Act of 2018 (ECRA) (see 50 U.S.C. Chapter 58 at § 4817), in which Congress directed BIS to establish controls on the export, re-export and in-country transfers of “foundational technologies.” In this bulletin, we summarize what you can expect next from BIS and the key takeaways from this recent BIS action.

contentpilot/introduction

On August 13, 2018, Congress enacted the ECRA as part of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2019 (NDAA). The ECRA is the permanent statutory authority for the Export Administration Regulations (EAR), which is administered by BIS. In the ECRA, Congress authorized BIS to establish export controls on emerging and foundational technologies. The ECRA did not specifically identify emerging and foundational technologies that should be subject to controls, but instead described them as essential to the national security of the United States and those not already identified as “critical technologies” under section 1703(a)(6) of the Foreign Investment Risk Review Modernization Act (FIRRMA).

core/paragraph

What are Emerging and Foundational Technologies?

BIS has addressed “emerging technologies” and “foundational technologies” separately. On November 19, 2018, BIS issued an <a href="https://www.federalregister.gov/documents/2018/11/19/2018-25221/review-of-controls-for-certain-emerging-technologies">ANPRM</a> identifying broad categories of potential emerging technologies (“Emerging Technologies ANPRM”), indicating that a separate notice for foundational technologies was forthcoming. The Emerging Technologies ANPRM identified 14 representative general categories of technology &nbsp;to determine whether there were specific emerging technologies within those that were essential to national security including, but not limited to: biotechnology; artificial intelligence (AI); position, navigation and timing technology; microprocessor technology; advanced computing technology; data analytics; quantum information and sensing technology; robotics; certain logistics technology; additive manufacturing; brain-computer interfaces; hypersonics; advanced materials; and advanced surveillance technologies. For more information on the emerging technologies ANPRM, please see Thompson Hine <a href="https://www.trumpandtrade.com/2018/11/commerce-requests-comments-emerging-technology-controls/">Update of November 19, 2018</a>.

On January 6, 2020, BIS issued the first of several expected “emerging technology” <a href="https://www.govinfo.gov/content/pkg/FR-2020-01-06/pdf/2019-27649.pdf">interim final rules</a> to control artificial-intelligence based software specifically designed to automate geospatial imagery analysis and point clouds to ECCN 0D521, which as of that date requires an export license for export or re-export to all destinations except Canada.

The Foundational Technologies ANPRM, published on August 27, 2020, did not similarly identify representative categories of foundational technologies, but did provide some useful examples for the types of end-uses and end-users that may trigger controls. Specifically, this ANPRM seeks industry guidance to identify the types of “enabling technologies, including tooling, testing and certification equipment” that should be subject to additional controls, and included the following examples:

The ANPRM states that foundational technology is something that is “essential to innovation” and “essential to the national security of the United States,” and it also notes that the term includes not only “technology” but also “commodities” and software.”&nbsp; Ultimately, it may be that some foundational technology may be broadly controlled under a Commerce Control List (CCL) category in the EAR; however, it appears likely that the determination of whether much foundational technology is controlled will depend on specific applications or end-uses under any final Rule.&nbsp; BIS officials have stated that the rulemaking is focused on ensuring that other countries do not gain an advantage over the United States.

Key Takeaways from the Foundational Technologies ANPRM

As noted, the Foundational Technologies ANPRM seeks guidance from industry to identify foundational technologies warranting additional controls. The ANPRM itself, however, does not provide a list or categories of the specific items to seek public reaction. Thus, the first round of comments may be fairly general and lead to a second proposed rulemaking. Interested parties and industry members will have until October 26, 2020 to submit public comments on what the items should be and the impact of any export controls. New controls on foundational technologies do not appear to be imminent. However, BIS may issue interim rules on specific technologies prior to broader action, as they have done for certain “emerging” technologies.

2. BIS did not provide much detail on what foundational technologies it intends to control.

Unlike the Emerging Technologies ANPRM, the Foundational Technologies ANPRM does not provide a list of specific categories BIS is considering for export controls.&nbsp; However, it does provide some useful examples of the type of foundational technology BIS is focusing on and potential applications. For example, the controls will likely be limited to those relevant to manufacturing, testing and certification tools, systems and software, with the following potential applications: semi-conductor manufacturing, weapons of mass destruction, data analysis collection and surveillance.&nbsp; The lack of detail may signal the difficulty inherent in controlling foundational technology.

3. BIS appears to focus on military end-use and end-user restrictions for foundational technologies.

The examples in the Foundational Technologies ANPRM focus on national security issues tied to specific end-uses or end-users. For example, technologies used: (i) for indigenous military innovation efforts in China, Russia or Venezuela; (ii) to enable innovation in developing weapons, enabling foreign intelligence collection activities, or weapons of mass destruction; or (iii) further foreign military or intelligence capabilities in countries of concern or development of weapons of mass destruction. The result of this rulemaking may be new controls that only apply to certain end-users or end-uses, unlike most current controls that are country-based.

How Will These Controls Impact Foreign Investment and CFIUS?

FIRRMA, also a part of the NDAA, added “emerging and foundational technologies” to the list of critical technologies from a national security perspective. The Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) has implemented rules mandating notification to CFIUS of certain foreign investment in companies with critical technology.

Given the lack of specific detail in the Foundational Technologies ANRPM, it’s even more important for investors and exporters to monitor any new controls on foundational technologies that may emerge in the coming months. New BIS controls may affect the scope of CFIUS jurisdiction in the coming months.

How Can I Submit Public Comments on Foundational Technologies to BIS?

BIS is seeking industry guidance on the following topics:

Interested parties may submit public comments in response to the Foundational Technologies ANPRM until October 26, 2020, as follows:&nbsp;

Thompson Hine LLP’s <a href="https://www.thompsonhine.com/services/international-trade">International Trade</a> practice group has extensive experience in export controls and addressing concerns and submitting comments to BIS in rulemaking notices.

David M. Schwartz Partner and Practice Group Leader, International Trade 202.263.4170 <a href="mailto:David.Schwartz@ThompsonHine.com">David.Schwartz@ThompsonHine.com</a>

Francesca M.S. Guerrero Partner, International Trade 202.973.2774 <a href="mailto:Francesca.Guerrero@thompsonhine.com">Francesca.Guerrero@thompsonhine.com</a>

Samir D. Varma Partner, International Trade 202.263.4136 <a href="mailto:Samir.Varma@ThompsonHine.com">Samir.Varma@ThompsonHine.com</a>

Brent Connor Senior Counsel, International Trade 202.263.4188 <a href="mailto:Brent.Connor@ThompsonHine.com">Brent.Connor@ThompsonHine.com</a>

Joyce Rodriguez Associate, International Trade 202.973.2724 <a href="mailto:Joyce.Rodriguez@ThompsonHine.com">Joyce.Rodriguez@ThompsonHine.com</a>

Scott E. Diamond* Senior Legislative &amp; Regulatory Policy Advisor, International Trade 202.263.4197 <a href="mailto:Scott.Diamond@ThompsonHine.com">Scott.Diamond@ThompsonHine.com</a> *Not licensed to practice law

This advisory bulletin may be reproduced, in whole or in part, with the prior permission of Thompson Hine LLP and acknowledgment of its source and copyright. This publication is intended to inform clients about legal matters of current interest. It is not intended as legal advice. Readers should not act upon the information contained in it without professional counsel.

This document may be considered attorney advertising in some jurisdictions.

https://admin.thompsonhine.com/wp-content/uploads/2022/04/BIS_Publishes_Advance_Notice_of_Proposed_Rulemaking_to_Identify_and_Review_Controls_on_Foundational_Technologies.pdf

BIS Publishes Advance Notice of Proposed Rulemaking to Identify and Review Controls on Foundational Technologies: What’s Next?

Services